Cabinet committee blocked plan to double Australia’s support to Pacific, election-eve leak reveals | Australian foreign policy

The Morrison government has been hit by an election-eve leak that the cabinet’s national security committee blocked a proposal by the foreign affairs minister, Marise Payne, to double Australia’s support to the Pacific.

Labor said the “extraordinary” pre-election leak, first reported by the Australian newspaper, showed the government was “falling apart”, while Scott Morrison insisted the committee was “extremely tight”.

The revelation was expected to trigger renewed debate about the government’s Pacific policy in the wake of China signing a security deal with the Solomon Islands.

Guardian Australia has confirmed that the proposed advanced by Payne included approximately doubling Australia’s total financial support to Pacific island countries over four years.

This package included foreign aid, but the measures proposed to the national security committee are believed to have been broader.

The proposal was partly driven by concerns that if Australia did not ramp up support to its friends and neighbors in the Pacific, the gap would be filled by others, including China.

The policy, described internally as the next stage of the government’s Pacific step-up program, was being developed late last year, and discussions continued into early 2022.

The national security committee did not adopt the entire package, although some elements were salvaged.

For example, the budget handed down in March by the treasurer, Josh Frydenberg, included $350m in temporary and targeted support to assist the Pacific with Covid-19 recovery.

The national security committee, chaired by Morrison, is responsible for decisions on major issues of strategic significance, and its deliberations are usually tightly held.

Australian foreign policy

Its deputy chair is Barnaby Joyce, and the other members are Frydenberg, Payne, Peter Dutton, Simon Birmingham, Karen Andrews, and Michaelia Cash.

When a reporter asked Morrison on Friday why members of his government were leaking against him, Morrison said he rejected that accusation “100%”.

The prime minister defended his ministerial colleagues. “My national security committee has been extremely tight,” he said.

Morrison said such meetings were “not just attended by ministers” but were “also attended by officials” – but he stopped short of saying he would launch a leak investigation.

While declining to confirm or deny the report’s substance, he pushed back at the idea that increasing funding would thwart China’s activities in the region.

“You’re suggesting if you double funding in the Pacific, somehow the Chinese government doesn’t have any influence or won’t be seeking to coerce or exert its influence,” Morrison told reporters in Perth. “That assumption doesn’t hold.”

Labor’s foreign affairs spokesperson, Penny Wong, said the pre-election leak was “extraordinary”.

“What this shows again is Mr. Morrison dropping the ball,” Wong told ABC Radio National. “They simply did not ensure that they looked at how Australia could ensure we were the partner of choice.

“How do we ensure that we secure our region? That’s the key strategic question. And on this, Mr. Morrison dropped the ball, and Australian security is paying the price.”

Birmingham did not deny the substance of the story in the Australian.

Sign up to receive an email with the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning.

“There’s no shortage of willingness from our government to invest,” the finance minister told ABC Radio National on Friday. “I’m just emphasizing we have acted on much advice from Marise and increased support in the Pacific.”

Birmingham said he would not enter into a public “debate” about the story, and Payne was “not going to debate what does or does not go to cabinet either”.

Morrison has repeatedly argued that the government was not blindsided by the emergence of security negotiations between China and the Solomon Islands, which led to the signing of a deal in the early stages of the Australian election campaign.

After the signing, Morrison said Australia and the US shared the same “red line” when opposing a Chinese military base in the Solomon Islands, without specifying what action might be triggered if that line were crossed.

Morrison has argued China is exerting “enormous pressure” on Pacific island countries and has dismissed claims from Labor that the deal represents the biggest Australian foreign policy failure in the Pacific since the second world war.

On Thursday, he said he wanted to visit the Solomon Islands and other Pacific island countries if re-elected on Saturday.

Labor’s costings, released on Thursday, included a pledge to add $538m to Australia’s foreign aid budget for the Pacific over the next four years. The Labor policy is part of a broader package of measures to “restore Australia’s place as the first partner of choice for our Pacific family”.

Dutton has repeatedly argued that China has taken an “aggressive” approach and operates “by very different rules” to deepen its regional influence.

Some of the rhetoric has angered the prime minister of Solomon Islands, Manasseh Sogavare, who said the country was being treated like kindergarten children.

In April, the head of the Office of National Intelligence, Andrew Shearer, denied that there had been an Australian intelligence failure, insisting that China had long been interested in expanding its presence across the Indo-Pacific.

New Zealand’s foreign affairs minister, Nanaia Mahuta, later characterized it as “a relationship failure” in an interview with the Guardian.

On Friday, the Australian government said total support to the Pacific was $2.7bn this financial year. That figure included loans, security programs, health and financial aid, and “a record $1.85bn in official development assistance”.

“We are easily the largest bilateral donor to the Pacific,” a government spokesperson said, pointing to the opening of six new diplomatic missions in the Pacific since 2018 and the doubling of the lending capacity of the Australian infrastructure financing facility for the Pacific, from $1.5bn to $3bn.

Bella E. McMahon
I am a freelance writer who started blogging in college. I am fascinated by human nature, politics, culture, technology, and pop culture. In addition to my writing, I enjoy exploring new places, trying out new things, and engaging in conversations with new people. Some of my favorite hobbies are reading, playing music, making crafts, writing, traveling, and spending time with my family.